Last updated November 18, 2026 · ranked from 3,700 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 9 pizza places in and around Waterford, MI, led by Anthony's Pizza & Party, Buscemis Waterford and Cottage Inn Pizza Waterford. Together they have 3,700 Google reviews; Buscemis Waterford has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.6. Every place on the list is in Waterford, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
Top picks at a glance
1Buscemis WaterfordBuscemis Waterford holds a 4.6 Google rating across 336 reviews, listed on Google as pizza takeout.
Anthony's Pizza & Party holds a 4.5 Google rating across 563 reviews, listed on Google as pizza.
New York–style pies
Breadsticks and garlic sauce
Takeout and delivery
“This place is the epitomy of a retro-nostalgia trip favorite for waterford. I love the pizza and breadsticks, the vibe in the store is amazing like you're right back in the 80s again. Definetly would be a spot for the whole cast of stran…”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each pizza place is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Waterford category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which pizza place in Waterford, MI has the highest Google rating?
Scalzo's Pizzeria & Bakery has the highest rating in this guide: 4.8 from 1,169 reviews. Calabrese's Pizzeria II follows at 4.7 from 448 reviews, with Buscemis at 1325 W Huron St scoring 4.6 from 336 reviews.
Where can I sit down for pizza in Waterford, MI?
Calabrese's Pizzeria II, Anthony's Pizza & Party and Guido's at 2510 Airport Rd offer dine-in service. Calabrese's has high chairs and a wheelchair-accessible restroom. Guido's has seating, Wi-Fi and vegetarian offerings.