Last updated October 5, 2026 · ranked from 3,666 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 10 pizza places in and around Waterford, MI, led by Scalzo's Pizzeria & Bakery, Calabrese's Pizzeria II and Mike's Pizza and Catering. Together they have 3,666 Google reviews; Wheezys Pizza & Shawarma has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.9. Every place on the list is in Waterford, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
A 4.8 Google rating from 1,169 reviews anchors Scalzo's Pizzeria & Bakery at No. 1 in Waterford, MI. Reviewers describe repeat orders, consistently delicious pizza, and generous sizing, with one noting that a medium is as big as a large. The counter-service shop on Elizabeth Lake Road emphasizes handcrafted pizzas, including a 16-inch Deluxe pie, and also offers wings and dessert. A children's menu, takeout, curbside pickup, and free on-site parking add practical reasons to choose it for pizza night.
Handcrafted pizzas
Curbside pickup
Children's menu
“My boys and I are having pizza night and after a great experience the first time, I wanted to order some more. I'm currently standing in my kitchen saying to myself "man this is some good pizza."
You can tell these pizzas were made with…”
Chicago-style pies and review praise for reliable quality help put Calabrese's Pizzeria II at No. 2 in Waterford, MI. This compact counter-service spot at 4668 Dixie Hwy holds a 4.7 Google rating from 448 reviews, with a listed price level in the lowest cost tier. One reviewer says the food is still made the same way; another praises its longevity and commitment to quality. Dine-in seating and takeout cover both sit-down meals and food to go, with hearty subs and ample pasta portions rounding out the menu.
Chicago-style pies
Budget-friendly price tier
Dine-in and takeout
“Delicious food as always
Still made the same way it always was”
A 4.7-star Google rating from 302 reviews gives Mike's Pizza and Catering a clear basis for its No. 3 spot among pizza places in Waterford, MI. Located at 3487 Sashabaw Rd, it pairs that rating with a listed price level of 1, the lowest category on the supplied scale. Those two factors—customer ratings and a low price classification—make it a useful pick for readers weighing both reputation and budget when choosing where to get pizza.
A 4.9 Google rating from 77 reviews gives Wheezys Pizza & Shawarma a clear numerical basis for its No. 4 spot among pizza places in Waterford, MI. Listed as a pizza place, the business pairs pizza and shawarma in its name. Find it at 2891 Pontiac Lake Rd, Suite 102, in Waterford, MI; the suite number is a useful detail when locating the address.
A low listed price tier and a 4.6-out-of-5 Google rating put Sir Pizza at No. 5 among pizza places in Waterford, MI. The rating draws on 257 reviews, giving customer feedback a meaningful role in its placement. Located at 4674 W Walton Blvd, the pizza business pairs that review record with the lowest price category in the supplied listing. Those two factors make it a useful option for readers who weigh both cost and customer ratings when choosing pizza.
Positive pizza reviews and fast counter service earn Buscemis Waterford the No. 6 spot in Waterford, MI. At 1325 W Huron St, this casual lunch stop has a 4.6 Google rating from 336 reviews and falls in the supplied data’s lowest price tier. Reviewers praise the pizza, with one highlighting the owner’s willingness to special-order and keep favorites in stock. Takeout, delivery, and free parking add convenience, while midnight closing on Friday and Sunday gives customers a late-night option.
Fast counter service
Takeout and delivery
Friday midnight closing
“got a delicious sausage calzone and the staff was very sweet :) ty guys!!”
A 4.5-star Google rating from 263 reviews gives Saroki's Crispy Chicken & Pizza a clear basis for the No. 7 spot among pizza places in Waterford, MI. Located at 5010 Highland Rd, the business is listed as a pizza place and puts both chicken and pizza in its name. Its listed price level is 2, adding a practical cost reference alongside that strong overall customer score.
A low listed price tier and a 4.5-star Google rating from 188 reviews earn Green Lantern Pizza the No. 8 spot among pizza places in Waterford, MI. Located at 5820 Highland Rd, it gives readers comparing local options a straightforward combination of price and customer ratings to consider. Its price level of 1 is the lowest tier in the supplied listing, making it particularly relevant for those using cost as a starting point for choosing pizza.
New York–style pies and a retro atmosphere give Anthony's Pizza & Party its character at No. 9 in Waterford, MI. The counter-serve spot on Williams Lake Road has a 4.5-star Google rating from 563 reviews, with reviewers praising the pizza, square slices, breadsticks and garlic sauce. One longtime customer reports visiting since childhood, while another describes the store as an ’80s nostalgia trip. Takeout and delivery are central to the operation, with casual dine-in available without table service.
New York–style pies
Breadsticks and garlic sauce
Takeout and delivery
“This place is the epitomy of a retro-nostalgia trip favorite for waterford. I love the pizza and breadsticks, the vibe in the store is amazing like you're right back in the 80s again. Definetly would be a spot for the whole cast of stran…”
A 4.7-star Google rating from 64 reviews earns Mia’s Pizzeria Brick Oven Pizza the No. 10 spot among pizza places in Waterford, MI. Located at 3417 Elizabeth Lake Rd, it puts brick oven pizza front and center in its name. The strong aggregate rating is the clearest reason for its inclusion, while its Elizabeth Lake Road address gives readers a straightforward location to look up.
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each pizza place is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Waterford category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which pizza place in Waterford, MI has the highest Google rating?
Scalzo's Pizzeria & Bakery has the highest rating in this guide: 4.8 from 1,169 reviews. Calabrese's Pizzeria II follows at 4.7 from 448 reviews, with Buscemis at 1325 W Huron St scoring 4.6 from 336 reviews.
Where can I find Detroit-style, Chicago-style or NY-style pizza in Waterford, MI?
Jet's Pizza at 4238 Pontiac Lake Rd serves Detroit-style pizza with flavored crusts. Calabrese's Pizzeria II at 4668 Dixie Hwy serves Chicago-style pies, while Anthony's Pizza & Party at 6301 Williams Lake Rd offers NY-style pies.
Which pizza places in Waterford, MI stay open latest?
Pizza Hut at 4297 Highland Rd, Domino's at 3925 Elizabeth Lake Rd B and Hungry Howie's at 4212 Highland Rd close at 1 a.m. Friday and Saturday. Sunday through Thursday, Pizza Hut and Domino's close at midnight, while Hungry Howie's closes at 11 p.m.
Where can I sit down for pizza in Waterford, MI?
Calabrese's Pizzeria II, Anthony's Pizza & Party and Guido's at 2510 Airport Rd offer dine-in service. Calabrese's has high chairs and a wheelchair-accessible restroom. Guido's has seating, Wi-Fi and vegetarian offerings.
Which pizza places in Waterford, MI offer curbside pickup or no-contact delivery?
Scalzo's and Guido's offer curbside pickup. Guido's also offers no-contact delivery, as do Pizza Hut, Domino's, Jet's, Hungry Howie's and Cottage Inn at 47 S Cass Lake Rd.
1
